New Orleans Saints win over Miami Dolphins most impressive in franchise history

Written by Les East Monday, 26 October 2009 22:55

Saints News

The New Orleans Saints’ 46-34 victory at Miami on Sunday was the most impressive triumph in the history of the franchise.

It wasn’t the biggest win – until New Orleans reaches a Super Bowl, the 27-24 divisional playoff victory against Philadelphia in the 2006 season will forever hold that distinction.

It wasn’t as historic as others such as the 20-16 victory at Pittsburgh in 1987, which clinched the first winning record, or the 27-3 victory at Arizona (then called Phoenix), which clinched the first division title.

It wasn’t the most emotional win – that was the 23-3 Monday nighter against the Falcons that christened the reopening of the Superdome in 2006.

It wasn’t the most dominant win – that could be the 42-17 win at Dallas in 2006 or the 42-0 pasting of the Broncos in 1988.

It didn’t have the novelty of the 21-20 victory at the Jets that enabled the 1980 team to sidestep a 0-16 record or the 19-16 victory over the Lions via Tom Dempsey’s record 63-yard field goal in 1973.

But when it comes to the whole package – the importance of the game, the quality of the opposition, the ability to overcome significant adversity in a season previously devoid of adversity, the size of the deficit overcome, and the manner in which it was done – this victory was singular.

One of the reasons it’s the most impressive win is that for nearly half the game the Saints were so utterly unimpressive in digging themselves a hole seemingly too deep to climb out of.

Having been nearly perfect at the start of each of their first five games, all of which they won easily, they sputtered out of the gate as a Marques Colston drop and a Jon Stinchcomb false-start derailed the first possession.

After that it was clear the Dolphins were a better prepared, more determined, better focused, and sharper team that was playing about as well as it could.

They thoroughly whipped the Saints’ offensive line throughout the first half and enjoyed a 24-3 lead that seemed headed to 31-3 late in the second quarter.

Then New Orleans caught two breaks – a fumble recovery by Scott Shanle that stopped Miami and gave the Saints a scoring opportunity, which came only after a booth review that gave a borderline call to New Orleans.

By the way, the “this-could-only-happen-to-the-Saints” replay malfunction ruling notwithstanding, New Orleans is in the midst of its greatest two-week run with officials in the history of the franchise. Two weeks ago against the Giants, New York cornerback Corey Webster was called for pass interference against Colston when the pair’s feet got tangled accidentally. The 35-yard infraction set up a touchdown.

In the same game, a booth review determined that the ball was coming loose but wasn’t a fumble on a Shanle fumble return, setting up another touchdown.

Then on Sunday came the second Shanle call, the Colston catch and fumble that could have been an incompletion (or a completion that would have run out the clock) that followed shortly thereafter, and the Darren Sharper-scored-a-touchdown-before-he-fumbled ruling were all borderline calls, all important plays, and all went the Saints way – every single one of them. What in the name of Grover Klemmer is going on here?

OK, now back to the turnaround. After the Shanle recovery and the Colston catch that was marked inside the one, Sean Payton inexplicably sent John Carney on to the field to kick a field goal that would have made it 24-6 and sent the Dolphins into halftime feeling like they had snuffed out the Saints’ last gasp.

Even more inexplicably, Miami coach Tony Sparano called timeout, giving Drew Brees time to talk some sense into Payton and Brees ran on the field and leaped over the top for a touchdown and a 24-10 halftime score that left the Saints at least fogging the mirror.

Here’s what’s most important about the Saints’ 36-10 dominance in the second half – Payton’s commitment to the run game made the difference. New Orleans was trailing, 27-17, midway through the third quarter and Payton put Mike Bell in the game and ran right at the Dolphins. The tired defense got a chance to catch its breath, the offensive line got a chance to dish out a little of what it had been taking in pass protection, and the game turned.

Perhaps the most amazing stat in a game filled with amazing stats was that the Saints outrushed the Dolphins. Miami, the top running team in the NFL, was dominating in the run game while building its early lead. The Saints, who didn’t get their running game going until they were down by multiple scores, wiped out that advantage, rushing for one more yard for the game. Payton has taken a cute passing game and turned it into a tough, multi-faceted offense.

One last thing about the second half – Carney’s missed extra point, for which snapper Jason Kyle and especially holder Mark Brunell share the blame. That left the Saints with a precarious 37-34 lead and a still precarious 40-34 lead later. Virtually any other Saints team would have lost that game, 41-40 – you just know they would have. But not this team.

A rally from a 21-point deficit, a quarterback who overcomes four turnovers and talks his coach into a game-turning decision, a coach who clearly has matured in his fourth season, a defense that adjusts and scores, a really good team that is a team in every sense, and even help from the officials – this victory had it all.

That’s why it’s more impressive than any of the 269 previous victories in Saints history. And with the way this season is going, you can’t help but wonder if it too will be surpassed some time between now and February.